Tara (Charles Dickens’ servant, played by Anna Murphy): Is Tiny Tim dead?
Scrooge: Well, of course he is, imbecile.
Charles Dickens: He was very ill.
Scrooge: You can’t save every child in London.
Charles Dickens: And the family has no money for a doctor.
Tara: Then Scrooge must save him!
Charles Dickens: He wouldn’t…
Charles Dickens: Well, he’s too selfish.
Tara: He can change, there’s good in him, somewhere. I know it.
Scrooge: People don’t change.
Charles Dickens: He’s been this way, for a long time. I’m not sure he can change.
Tara: Of course he can, he’s not a monster.
Scrooge: I thought this was a ghost story, not a fairy tale.
Forty people joined us for the Friends’ screening of the 2017 film The Man Who Invented Christmas. It tells the story of how Charles Dickens (Dan Stevens) wrote and published “A Christmas Carol” during a frantic six weeks in the run up to Christmas 1843. Many thanks to Wendy the Picture House manager and her team for making the arrangements.
It is easy to underestimate the challenge of writing and publishing a book (or making a film for that matter) to a very tight deadline with a very limited budget. Dickens had written Oliver Twist in 1838 but that had been followed by three unsuccessful books. He often had writer’s block, was heavily in debt, and had a large family to support. He could easily have ended up in a debtors’ prison as his father did. Despite this A Christmas Carol became one of the best selling books of all time and went on to influence the way Christmas is celebrated across the world.
This film is not a documentary but does draw upon Dickens’ life experiences, including the ridicule he faced as a child while forced to work in a blacking (metal polish) factory. It’s worth watching for the locations, costumes and the photography, and especially for its portrayal of Dickens’ interactions with the characters which highlights the creative struggle at the moral core of the book, And I enjoyed spotting Christopher Plummer, Jonathan Pryce, Miriam Margolyes, Miles Jupp and Simon Callow among the cast.
However. the film treats lightly the deep flaws in Dickens’ personality, including his recklessness and instability and his ill treatment of his wife. In my view the film is a very interesting “one-watch” but too sentimental to become a regular feature of Christmas screenings,
Agree/disagree? We welcome your comments or reviews below.
2 thoughts on “Review: The Man Who Invented Christmas”
This seems to be a fair assessment of the movie. It is worth noting that sentimentality was a stock-in-trade of Dickens’ writings. Indeed, it is a stock-in-trade of Christmas movies; ‘A Very Yorkshire Christmas’ (1919) has an even larger amount.
Bill is right about the movies’ weakness in depicting the darker aspects of the times, the book and, indeed, the writer. ‘The Invisible Woman (1913) does address the latter: with a fine cast led by Ralph Fiennes: but we will need to wait for the 35mm projectors to be running to revisit that film
Very much enjoyed this review. I wasn’t able to attend the screening but I have seen the film before. I can’t wait for the return of HPPH and will try to tune in to the A Friends AGM to get an update on progress. Happy 2022!